A Tangipahoa Parish judge on Nov. 12 ordered Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase and other prediction market platforms to stop serving Louisiana, hours after Attorney General Liz Murrill sued them as unlicensed gambling operations. The order is temporary, but its instinct is wrong for a state that wants capital and new technology.
The 21st Judicial District Court judge signed the restraining order ex parte, without hearing from the companies, and required no bond. It bars 31 corporate entities from offering event contracts on sports, elections, awards and anything else the state treats as sports wagering to anyone in Louisiana without a state sports-wagering license and permit. It also orders them to geofence the state. The order lasts 10 days, expiring about Nov. 22 unless extended. Polymarket US has since moved the case to federal court, where the order stands unless a federal judge lifts it, as two defendants have asked. The state, in turn, wants the case sent back to state court. The suit, as KPLC reported, accuses the platforms of breaking state gambling law. "It's not complicated: if you aren't a licensed gaming operator, you aren't legal," Attorney General Murrill said after the ruling.
She is on solid ground under state law. Act 182, in effect since Aug. 1, expressly lets the Attorney General ask a court for this kind of order against gambling by computer. Louisiana's regulated gaming industry also pays real taxes, as the state's casino revenue figures show. The harder questions are whether federal law displaces the state's and whether shutting the door is good policy. On both, Louisiana is making the wrong bet.
A prediction market is an exchange. Buyers and sellers trade yes-or-no contracts on future events, the price reflects the crowd's odds, and the exchange earns a fee instead of betting against its customers. Kalshi has been a federally designated contract market since 2020, and the Commodity Exchange Act gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) exclusive jurisdiction over futures and swaps traded on those markets. Whether event contracts fit that definition is the heart of the suit Kalshi filed against state officials in the Western District of Louisiana on Oct. 23. Polymarket US filed a similar one in the Eastern District four days later. Kalshi has moved to withdraw its request for a federal restraining order, and Judge Jerry Edwards Jr. will hear its preliminary injunction request on Monday, Nov. 23.
U.S. prediction exchanges reported $120.7 billion in contract volume in October, up 64 percent from September, according to DeFi Rate's count across eight exchanges. That counts contracts at a dollar apiece rather than cash wagered, and multi-outcome combo contracts drove most of the recent growth. Kalshi raised $1 billion at a $40 billion valuation in late October from a group that includes Wellington, Sequoia and Morgan Stanley Investment Management, and it reports more than 30 million accounts. Intercontinental Exchange, which owns the New York Stock Exchange, has invested more than $1.6 billion in Polymarket and is its largest disclosed shareholder. Louisiana adults should be free to choose these markets too.
Louisiana has spent years courting this kind of company. The state has put public money into a fund for homegrown tech startups, and its economic development pitch rests on predictability, the same pitch it makes when it competes for industrial projects. One Louisiana tribe has already moved. In September the Tunica-Biloxi Tribe, which owns Paragon Casino Resort in Marksville, announced a prediction market app, to be run by its SaltTrade venture on Kalshi's exchange. A state that shuts the door on the sector shouldn't expect it to hire here.
On Nov. 5 the CFTC gave federally regulated exchanges 30 days to drop state-by-state geographic restrictions or explain why they can't. "Derivatives markets must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale," CFTC Chairman Michael Selig said. A week later a Louisiana court ordered exchanges, and the brokers that connect to them, to build exactly that kind of fence. The next day the CFTC sued to block it. The appeals courts are split. The Third Circuit sided with Kalshi against New Jersey in April. The Ninth and Sixth Circuits went the other way, holding that sports contracts likely aren't swaps, and petitions are waiting at the Supreme Court. No national market can run on 50 rulebooks. Business groups that fight patchwork regulation everywhere else should say so here.
These markets are also information tools. A February paper by Federal Reserve Board economists suggests that Kalshi's macroeconomic markets provide a "high-frequency, continuously updated, distributionally rich benchmark that is valuable to both researchers and policymakers." The order's catch-all for anything "considered sports wagering" is broad, and it isn't yet clear whether it reaches contracts beyond sports, elections and awards. Kalshi lists a natural gas contract that settles on the Henry Hub spot price, the national benchmark set in Erath. If the order reaches that far, it would fence Louisiana off from a contract tied to its own gas benchmark, a strange outcome.
The state's best argument is about young people, and it deserves a straight answer. Rutgers researchers who surveyed 1,677 Americans ages 13 to 27 found that about 40 percent of those who bet on prediction markets were high-risk problem gamblers, nearly four times the rate for other forms of gambling. That should trouble every Louisiana parent, and the industry has to own it. But the same researchers call for a federal gambling regulator and national self-exclusion, and no state-by-state injunction can deliver either. We would add a 21-and-over rule for sports contracts and real insider-trading surveillance, which federal law already requires of exchanges. Kalshi has fined and suspended traders who used inside information. Rules like these can be written once and enforced everywhere.
Revenue is the other fair concern. The Attorney General says the platforms are trying to evade state regulators and taxes. Louisiana collected $67.9 million from mobile sportsbooks in fiscal 2024-25 at a 15 percent rate and has since raised that rate to 21.5 percent. The state knows how to bring a new industry inside the tent. A licensing or fee arrangement, worked out with Washington, would collect money that a shutdown never will.
Louisiana's leaders are well placed to get there. The Attorney General, the Governor and the state's congressional delegation carry real weight in Washington. They can push the CFTC and Congress for a national rulebook that protects young people and the integrity of the games. That gets Louisiana the protection it wants and keeps the state open to one of the fastest-growing corners of American finance.